Pages

Friday, August 3, 2012

Reforming Investments by Local Government in Nepal

The government of Nepal has shifted investment towards environment friendly infrastructures development, increasing revenues without compromising environmental integrity of natural resources and green economy taking into account to climate proof infrastructures and adaptation activities. Context Since the early 1990s, when resources and authority began to be channeled through local government bodies, the use of heavy equipment for road construction such as bulldozers and excavators started to increase. Furthermore, the desire to establish road connections quickly also resulted in the increased use of unsustainable road construction approaches and methods. Development of road network is a consensus priority at local levels, which has expedited with promulgation of LSGA (1999). Nearly 40 Mill US$ is spent annually on rural roads and every VDC spends nearly 1 mill NRs annually. Sand, gravel and Stones (SG&S) are a new-found source of revenue for many local governments (District Development Committees/Village Development Committees and Municipalities) after the promulgation of Local Self-Governance Act (LSGA 1999) and Local Self-Governance Regulations (LSGR 2000). Through LSGA and LSGR, local bodies have been given important rights to tax sell and regulate SG&S exports, the revenues from which are expected to help finance poverty reduction and inclusive/participatory local development Nepal has an abundance of SG&S resources which, if utilized judiciously, could help to shape Nepal's development and affluence. However, a balanced outlook on Nepal's SG&S sub-sector seems to be lacking. There are two extreme outlooks – one group trying to accumulate wealth at the cost of the environment and the other group opting to keep the resources intact and untouched. It is estimated that, Nepal government collects revenue from tax about Rs.1072 million per year. The annual value of environmental losses due to SG&S extraction, processing and transport estimated is Rs.206 million, or about 19 percent of the revenue generated. The situation has now improved after the Ministry of Federal Affairs and Local Development has made mandatory to local bodies that they should prepare the IEE/EIA studies of the Source Rivers and formulate environment management plans based on IEE/EIA findings. In many districts, only taxes from the transport of SG&S is being collected at road toll points, but actual extraction of the resource from the river bed or terrace is free. In fact, the SG&S resources need to be priced in all districts and this will be one avenue for increasing the revenue of the districts from SG&S. Government is in line with introducing a resource pricing system at least for control in resource extraction technology and amount, which could be nominal to start with, in order not to distort the competitiveness in the export market. Moreover, the financial and economic analysis shows that the SG&S trade, both domestic and export, is highly remunerative and a small extra resource pricing will not reduce the profitability and competitiveness to a considerable extent. At least Rs. 1.6 million in additional revenues per district can be raised by charging Rs.0.50 per cu.ft as the price of the resource. For resource pricing, initiation will be taken to adopt a system of extraction permits for each extraction zone (location), identified and recommended by the respective district IEE/EIA reports. Rural road construction will continue to be a priority at the local levels in future. It was revealed that heavy equipment based construction have started to substitute the traditional labor based and green road construction technologies in Nepal. Both technologies have their respective plus and minus points. Labor based technologies are considered environment-friendly and pro-poor with economic returns of 30% more than equipment based technology, but the technology is awfully slow and expensive. On the other hand, the heavy equipment based technologies generally have exactly opposite characteristics. Equipment based roads, can give good results, if planned properly. Wherever possible a combination of both approaches should be used (equipment based technology are cheaper and faster while the labor based technology are more sustainable and pro-poor). Nepal is highly affected by climate change. Climate change policy was formulated in 2011 to minimize the existing effects and likely impacts in different ecological regions—from the Southern plains to the middle hills and to the high Himalayan Mountains in the north, and their peoples, livelihoods, and ecosystems. To address the issues, efforts have been made from policy to institutional levels. Prior to the 15th Session of the Conference of the Parties (COP 15) to the UNFCCC, held in Copenhagen in 2009, the Government of Nepal organized a Cabinet Meeting at Kalapatthar, near the base camp of the Mount Everest, and issued the “Kalapatthar Declaration.” A Memorandum of Understanding was signed by 14 donors and development partners to support Nepal on climate change activities. The Interim Constitution of Nepal (2007) and Three-Year Interim Plan (2008-2010) have also addressed the issue of environmental management and climate change. Towards institutional front, the Government of Nepal established the Climate Change Management Division in the Ministry of Environment (MoE) in 2010. The MoE prepared the National Adaptation Programme of Action, which was endorsed by the Government on 28 September 2010. Local Adaptation Plans of Action (LAPAs) are being prepared to implement adaptation programmes. To coordinate climate change activities and implement collaborative programmes, a multi-stakeholder Climate Change Initiatives Coordination Committee (MCCICC) has been formed with representation from relevant ministries and institutions, international and national nongovernment organizations, academia, private sector, and donors. It is evident that institutional, collaborative and programmatic activities have been expanded to address the issue of climate change in recent years. Efforts to mobilise funds to implement the programmes on climate change are under way. Issues In the sand, gravel and stone sub sectors, declining pro-poor stance of the sand, gravel and stones (SG&S) sub-sector and no pricing administered for the most recently explored natural resources is considered as the major challenges for its effective management. The occurrence of spatial poverty is demonstrated by the fact that 30% of the country's 3915 VDC are yet to be linked to the road network and hence the development and expansion of road infrastructure in rural areas is obviously a consensus priority for local development across the country. In, Nepal, there are broadly two main road construction technologies in use for rural road construction, operation and maintenance: labor based and equipment based. Labor based technology (green road) has been gradually replaced by equipment based technology (non-engineered road) over the last 10-15 years with use of heavy equipments like bulldozers and excavators. Much of the climate change response within the Third Year Plan appears focused on Natural Resources Management including forests, agriculture, water and energy. However, there is no coherent definition and classification of climate change and climate change related expenditures. One of the most significant issues is how Nepal can meet the ambitious target of delivering and spending 80% of its adaptation finance at the local level. Strategies In order to increase the revenue from sand, gravel and stones, provision of environmental assessment tools like Initial Environment Examination and Environment Impact Assessment shall be employed strictly. In addition, mechanisms for SG&S resource pricing and permits for extraction shall be established. Moreover, part of the SG&S-derived revenues shall be plough back as investments in source river protection and addressing need of poor, women and impact communities. Whenever and wherever possible a blend of labor based and equipment based technologies shall be used for rural road construction to harness positive features of each technology. Cheaper and faster from equipment based technology and sustainable and poverty reducing from labor based technology. Climate change impacts the whole economy and broad range of sectors that needs to be taken into account. In this regard, climate resiliencies program shall be integrated into all aspects of national development through adopting integrated planning and budgeting schemes. Reform Process Policies are being formulated to enforce the provision of returning at least certain SG&S revenue to river ecosystem maintenance and investment in uplifting well being of SG&S impacted communities. Towards reforming investment in road sectors, local body's capacity and influences shall be strengthened to adopt environment friendly rural roads, pricing and ensuring benefits to deprived communities and deliver climate finance using a cross-sectoral approach. Similarly, reform process shall be initiated through strengthening capacity of local bodies to make them able to manage 80% of climate finance (currently estimated to be about 40%) and securing the right structures at the local level to ensure that the flow of climate finance reaches the most vulnerable communities. The government shall support inclusive green income and employment opportunities for poor and climate vulnerable groups whose health and livelihoods mostly depend on performance of natural resource management. In this regard, a possible starting point would be to integrate climate change, environment and poverty as an indicator of, or a component in, the Minimum Condition and Performance Measures (MCPM). Moreover, focus will be made to develop and implement integrated planning approaches for forestry, agriculture, irrigation, and energy and disaster mitigation as a means to adapt to climate change at the local level.

Thursday, May 31, 2012

Sustainable Management of Sand, Gravel and Stone in Nepal A. Background In pursuant of addressing emerging issues in Sand, Gravel and Stone (SG&S) sub-sector and recommending policies to address the challenges and making more efficient, effective and sustainable management system, the Ministry of Local Development has administered questionnaire survey in 75 districts in October 2011. In total, 26 districts responded questionnaire until December 2011. In addition, the Ministry through Poverty and Environment Initiative (PEI) Program under Local Governance and Community Development Program (LGCDP) commissioned a study on Current Practices of Revenue Generations from Natural Resources for the Local Bodies of Nepal in five districts of Nepal – Kailali, Rupandehi, Makawanpur, Dhadiing and Saptari in 2011. Likewise, to promote third party monitoring system, the Ministry entrusted Central Department of Environment Science to carry out study on effectiveness of implementation of Initial Environment Examination (IEE) reports in Dhading and Kabhre Districts in Nepal in 2011. Based on analysis of the questionnaire survey and aforementioned two studies, various issues in sustainable extraction of SG&S were identified and policy recommendations have been made accordingly. B. Issues and challenges 1. Resource ownership There is overlap, ambiguity and conflict about who owns the resource and is entitled to collect, extract or award contracts by levying charges. Local Self Governance Act (LSGA 1999) confers exclusive ownership of district based resources including SG&S to the District Development Committees (DDCs). Forest Act 1993 provides the same authority to the Ministry of Forests and Soil Conservation for the same resource lying within forest areas. According to the Forest Act, forest products are defined as “boulders, soil, stones, pebbles, sand” among others. Likewise, Security Forces, Wildlife Reserve, Custom Office and Buffer Zones are also collecting revenues from SG&Ss. In summary, because of having different windows for collecting revenues, conflicts amongst stakeholders have been on raise in this sub sector. While analyzing the questionnaire survey data, it was revealed that 28% DDC are realizing resource use conflicts with District Forest Offices. Even, community forests are charging tax for SG&S. Also, in the absence of clear administrative demarcation between forests and other lands, inter districts revenue collection conflicts have been reported in the boarder of Kapilbastu and Arghakhachi districts. 2. Effectiveness of IEE As per the Environment Protection Regulations (EPR 1997), extraction of SG&S up to 300 m3 per day requires IEE study. Out of the total 21 SG&S revenue generating survey districts, around 38% have carried out IEE thus far. It was revealed that some districts have undergone contractual agreement even without undertaking IEE/EIA study. Other districts are realizing problems with measurement of SG&S and raising questions on the cost effectiveness of the IEE study as such. As per the mandate of the IEE report, the excavation/collection of SG&S from different river systems has affected the entire watershed in Dhading and the cumulative effects have been observed in Trishuli River and Prithvi Highway. Sediment load is increased in the Trishuli River and the highway has been badly damaged, purportedly due to the movement of large trucks carrying SG&S. Given the complexity and integrated land use system, extracting SG&S from different river system only based on IEE study is in question. 3. Revenue sharing Some Terai districts are generating revenue through export tax on SG&S. Even, some of the districts are enjoying benefit of export tax that come out from other districts. For instance, Kailali DDC administers export tax for SG&S that originates from Knachanpur District. Kanchanpur District was of the view that they also should be entitled to receive part of the export tax. According to LSGA, between 35 and 50 percent of DDC revenues derived from SG&S taxes are expected to be shared with “concerned” Village Development Committees (VDCs), Municipalities, DFOs, and where applicable, Buffer Zone Committees. Almost two third of the entire survey districts are sharing revenues ranging from 18% in Pyuthan to 90% in Udayapur District with an average of 42% with local bodies including Municipalities and VDCs. 4. Income and expenditure The local bodies have been able to raise significant tax and other revenues from the SG&S subsector. However, these revenues have not been sufficiently ploughed back into the protection of the revenue sources – the rivers. In total, 48% of the total SG&S collecting survey districts are investing part of their income ranging from 4% in Nuwakot to 81% in Chitwan to environment protection. Though, the proportion figure is small, investment trend on environment protection has been on raise. For instance, 11% of the total income of 22 districts (Rs. 15, 44, 64,073) from this sub-sector in the country was invested in environment protection activities in 2009 while the proportion of income and investment in environment protection increased by 1% and 2% respectively in 2011. Chitwan district has invested mainly to undertake IEE study. Similarly, other districts have invested primarily in stream bank protection, plantation, awareness raising, disaster reduction and climate change. As per the given authority, different organizations have different tax rate for SG&S. For instance, following the LSGA, some districts are collecting upto 50% revenue while as per the Mining Act others are collecting only 10% revenues from SG&S sub-sector. 5. Monitoring and coordination Due to ineffective monitoring, coordination and law enforcement mechanism, state of impunity has been occurred in managing SG&S in some districts. In some study districts, “mafia” operations have controlled illegal exports of SG&S products, capturing contracts, carteling in contracts, not paying DDC tax as per contract (in Kailali), collecting ransom donations from the industries, transporting products without paying taxes, etc. If such a state of impunity continues unabated, it will spread to other districts. Sometimes SG&S are being collected from Churia Foot Hills, one of the youngest and fragile ecosystems in Nepal. Having effective coordination amongst stakeholders, regular monitoring and effective law enforcement in place would help enhancing effective management of SG&S. 6. Priority to local use Resource use priority should be given to local communities. For instances the drifted wood and other SG&S products of Parsa Wildlife Reserve has not been given priority to local development, instead they are supplying the resources to crusher industries. C. Policy recommendations • Prevailing policy conflicts over ownership of the SG&S sub sector should be resolved as soon as possible through adopting one door policy. It is recommended to give whole sole management authority of the SG&S sub-sector to DDC. The upcoming revised LSGA may need to address the issue tactfully. • Need to avail simple, cost effective and user friendly IEE/EIA study guidelines and formats to local bodies including DDC and Municipalities. The revised guidelines and formats need to include simple technology to measure SG&S. Devolution of ToR approval responsibilities to DDC with a provision of constituting a technical review team comprising of Local Development Officer, District Technical Officer, District Forest Officer, District Soil Conservation Officer and District Environment Focal Person would help improve the quality of IEE reports. • In line with the existing Regulations, DDCs should be reminded that the collection and extraction of SG&S resources within their jurisdictions is subject to IEE / EIAs study being conducted. • Considering the cumulative and integrated effects of interconnected river system, it is desirable to prefer EIA to IEE. • DDCs should be encouraged to plough back at least 20 percent of their SG&S revenue earnings from each river where extraction takes place, for river protection works such as embankments, putting concrete slabs to demarcate depths up to where the extraction can take place. • A mechanism should be envisioned for sharing part of export tax with the resource generating districts. • A more stringent Act should be formulated, promulgated and effectively enforced for punishing and sanctioning illegal extraction to end the current state of impunity. The revenue management, including taxation and revenue sharing system needs be made more transparent so that it helps minimizing state of impunity. • Identify environment sensitive areas and prohibit collecting SG&S from such sites and adopt site specific policies, especially resource extraction from foot hills of Chure should be strictly controlled. • Effective monitoring and feedback mechanism should be established and strengthened from central to district level. D. References • A Review of Current Practices of Revenue Generation from Natural Resources for the Local Bodies of Nepal, a report prepared by MLD in 2011 • Central level Environmental Monitoring of Sustainable Collection/extraction of Sand, Gravel and Boulders from rivers of Dhading and Kavre district, Nepal. A Study carried out by Central Department of Environmental Science, TU in 2011

Saturday, May 21, 2011

Poverty and Environment nexus in relation to rural development in Nepal

Intriduction
Environment and livelihood of local communities are linked very closely. Poverty is considered as a root cause as well as consequences of environmental degradation in Nepal. Environment friendly development supports maintaining fragile environment, while pro-poor development supports for a more robust livelihood for rural poor. In this regard, it is imperative to reform governance policy that supports pro-poor and pro-environment activities which is the very foundation of sustainable development. Therefore, for this to happen it warrants a strong policy commitment for restructuring and improving the overall governance of the environmental domain.

Economic Significance of Environmental Resources
Nepal’s economy is heavily reliant on natural resources – agricultural land, rangeland, mountain ecosystem, protected areas, wildlife, wetlands and forests. About 50% of the total income of the country is derived from natural resources based income like forest, fisheries, wetland, agriculture and tourism. Agriculture alone contributes over 50% of household income for over 80% of the total population of the country. Nepal depends heavily on traditional energy resources, which comprises 93.2% of total energy requirements. Nepal has witnessed a decrease in poverty levels from 42% in 1996 to 31% in 2004. However, there is a wide gap in poverty level between urban and rural areas which stand as high as 45%.

Resources are Being Depleted
Qualities of all the natural resources are being degraded rapidly due to over utilization and unsustainable use. Forests resources are being lost at the cost of expanding cultivated land and infrastructure development. Economic value of wetland resources are also being degenerated due to unsustainable agricultural practices in the peripheral areas and over utilization of wetland resources. Likewise, protected areas and wildlife are being threatened due to habitat loss and poaching incidence. Agricultural productivity despite the increasing coverage has been in decreasing due to excessive use of pesticides and chemical fertilizers. This together with natural hazard such as floods is expected to contribute to the annual loss of 20-25 tones/ha.

Poorer are the Hardest Hit
Natural resource dependent communities mainly the economically poor have been facing more problems compared to other income group in Nepal. In the absence of reliable alternative income and employment opportunities, poor people depend heavily on the natural resources for their subsistence need. Any changes in the resource asset will large impact the front line communities who are vulnerable to environmental shocks. Due to the loss and degradation, the drudgery for poor people has increased. They spend more time in the collection of water, firewood, fodder these days. In addition, indoor pollution has caused other heath related problems particularly, asthma, TB and vision problems. Due to the burgeoning problem, a large of number of unemployed youth leaves the country in search of employment opportunities.

Creating a “Win Win” Situation
Realizing the above scenario, it is clear that there is a clear linkage between the environment and poverty. If environment is degraded, the poorer people would be the ultimate losers. Since these variables have a positive correlation it is imperative to adopt a strategy that helps addressing both the issues simultaneously. The development should on one hand address the need of poor, while on the other it should take account of the already fragile ecosystem. In this regard, the development measures should take into account the facets of good ecology and economics. Poverty issues can be addressed by reforming the existing governance policy and institutional framework while environmental issue can be tackled through employing Social and Environmental Safeguard Framework strictly.

Address Poverty Issues
Towards the governance and institutional reforms, the decentralized process should include more poor families and minority ethnic groups in mainstream development process. The governance system should be able to address downward accountability and be socially inclusive. The field activities should be implemented through a mechanism where representation from local bodies and civil society are made mandatory, taking into account the need and aspirations of economically deprived communities. Policies and programs should give priority for people-centered development approach. Poor people need to be made a part and parcel of any development plan to make them the real owners and ultimate beneficiaries. In this regard, the local bodies should adequately allocate resources for pro poor families.

The government should co-manage and co-invest resources for the poor. In addition to the above, special focus should be given towards infrastructure development to create access to market and employment opportunities emanating from the above interventions.


Address Environmental Assets
Rural development should consider the importance of environmental assets that are so important for rural livelihood. In this regard, as environment is a cross cutting issue, it is imperative to manage environment more coherently through a partnership approach. From the policy level, an integrated planning framework that enhances multi sectoral coordination and partnership approach needs to be employed. In this regard, the role of National Planning Commission and Environment Protection Council could be very crucial. Ministry of Environment should be developed as a central lead agency to execute environment plan and programs.

As per the mandate given by the Local Self Governance Act and Regulations, an enabling environment should be created so that the Local Body can implement environment friendly development activities on their own. To ensure the environment friendly development, District Forests Coordination Committee in the district level can be made more functional. As per the size, location and cost of the sub projects, IEE or EIA needs to be strictly complied. If the aforementioned measures need to be taken seriously, then environment friendly rural development can be ensured.

Constraints/barriers
Presently, lack of elected government and fledgling capacity of the existing staff members are the major obstacles for effective implementation of the above mentioned activities. Likewise, in the name of forging political consensus for implementing activities, it sometime makes a sort of compromise and misuse of resources.

Conclusion
The environment and livelihood of local communities are inherently linked. To make the rural development sustainable, it is imperative that both poor as well as environment are safeguarded. Governance system should be reformed that address pro-poor and pro-environment policy, plan and programs.

Friday, April 29, 2011

Barhakund Lake Conservation: A case of payment for environmental services

Ek Raj Sigdel


The wetlands of Churia hills have been working as water reservoirs for centuries. However, these wetlands are under serious threat as a result of siltation and deforestation together with longer drought periods may be due to climate change, in recent years.

Take a case of Barhakunda- a network of 12 ponds- that ranges from quarter to one and half hectares areas are located at the Churia hills near Bhimdataa town (earlier known as Mahendra Nagar) of Kanchanpur District. Ever increasing population in the town and declaration of nearby forests as Suklaphanta Wildlife Reserve, increased pressure for firewood, fodder, timber and grazing in forest areas situated outside reserve - such as one around the Barhakunda. This resulted rapid loss of vegetation coverage, increased siltation and decreased water level in the ponds. This adversely affected the wildlife that depended on these ponds for water.

To address this issue, Western Terai Landscape Complex Project through Churia Conservation Network, a local NGO build a retention wall and planted bamboo and trees around the ponds, maintained inlets and outlets of the ponds. Besides, community were educated on need of plantation around barren areas surrounding Barhakunda and motivated to conserve and wisely use water resources. The aim was to retain water level and to make it a suitable habitat for wildlife species, and to provide water to nearby communities for farming and to maintain was for long times.

With three years of conservation efforts and local communities' participation the water level and greenery around the pond has significantly increased. Today, Barhakunda has been providing 78 local households including 18 Dalit households, water for irrigating their paddy fields of of Dalit community. Moreover, the Barhakunda has become a reliable source of drinking water to wildlife including leopards, pea-cocks, deers, and wild boars.

For maintenance of the wetland system, the community has made the scheme of raising income of Rs 10 per hour for irrigating their field. The generated money in turn has been utilized to hire a local guard for maintaining wetland. The rest of the money has been deposited in community forest account. In this way, a kind of understanding between community forest user group and the wetland user have been reached. This can be considered as a payment for environment services.

Saturday, March 26, 2011

Climate Change Adaptation Matrices and Western Terai Landscape Complex Project

Ek Raj Sigdel
Landscape Manager
Western Terai Landscape Complex Project is a joint undertaking of the government of Nepal, GEF, UNDP, SNV, WWF, Bio-versity International, NARC and LIBIRD. The eight year project, which is now running in six years, intends to conserve and sustainable use globally significant biodiversity resources of the Western Terai, lowland of Nepal, which is being included in two WWF Global 200 Eco-regions. The approach intends to address the issues of fragmentation of once extended habitat of the globally significant endangered wildlife species like elephants, tigers and rhinoceros.
The project has implemented wide ranged activities including forest management, watershed management, restoration of corridor and connectivity. The activities are additional to the regular government supported activities as they intend to benefit international communities. It has been realized that the landscape level biodiversity conservation activities address regular development objectivities as well as climate change adaptation issues. With this backdrop, it can be said that the Landscape Level Biodiversity Conservation contributes to livelihood improvement of local communities, conservation of biodiversity resources and also address the issues of climate change mitigation and adaptation.
The project has implemented wide ranged activities including documentation and replication of indigenous knowledge based adaptation practices, conservation of agro-biodiversity resources, and restoration of forests along corridor and connectivity areas like Bio-engineering along river side, plantation in degraded land, management of grassland, and restoration of watershed areas, maintenance of wetlands and promotion of non-timber forest based income generation activities.
While interacting with Tharu communities, local inhabitant in Shankarpur Village Development Committee of Kanchanpur District in Nepal, it was revealed that they have adapted some activities in response of flood damage. For instance, they have practiced storing agricultural production at second floor of building, river bank cultivation of groundnut, tomato, bottle gourd, cucumber, watermelon etc, early maturing rice plantation to escape flood (Chaite -4, Chaini, Hardinath, Radha-4, Anjana, Nimoi) and established community seed banks.
Western Terai Landscape Complex Project has piloted some community based conservation and livelihood development activities such as bio-engineering, restoration of corridor and connectivity, biogas promotion, water reservoir maintenance and non timber forest product management. These activities in one or another way are contributing to climate change adaptation.
Bio-engineering along the river bank has been carried out by using simple and low cost technology. Saccharum Munja, broom grass, bamboos and sand sacks are the key ingredient of this technology. It has been found very effective to control flood as the plant materials grow faster and helps withstanding flood pressure.
WTLCP’s role in maintaining corridor and connectivity has also helped facilitating dispersal of wild animals in different landscape matrices. In this regard, the project has carried out enrichment plantation and effective forest management exercise in the corridor and connectivity areas. Local communities are managing 3, 000 biogas plant which have helped a lot in reducing locals’ pressure on nearby forest resources. The strategy of increasing areas and enhancing quality of fragmented forest patches and connection of these patches to form corridor will be instrumental to escape the mega species from one place to another during emergency. This ultimately helps maintaining healthy population of the wildlife species as it supports maintaining gene pool of these creatures.
With the support of WTLCP, Water Reservoir along the foothills of Siwaliks / Churia has been maintained. Plantation around lakes, regulation of inlet, outlet and removal of invasive species has supported maintaining water levels. With this initiatives, water level of some of the lakes have been restored during winter seasons and this has become a new source of irrigation to local communities and become sustainable source of drinking water to wildlife species like peacock, deer and common leopard. It is hoped that the strategy of maintaining water reservoirs along the watershed region will help responding drought impact of climate change in a long run.
Non Timber Forest Product based income generation activities are considered as a major component of this project. Camommile, mint and lemon grasses are the key herb species that have been promoted to cultivate along the buffer zone of protected areas. Local people are getting three crops instead of the previous trend of harvesting only two crops i.e. rice and wheat. The crops are not palatable to wildlife species and hence contributing to deter wild animals. This has become a viable option to minimize wildlife people conflict in and around protected areas. In addition, the strategy will be instrumental for diversifying livelihood opportunities to local communities which would be necessary to respond climate change impact.
Aforementioned activities are additional activities of the government’s regular development programs which are designed and implemented as part of enhancing incremental benefits of biodiversity conservation.

Adaptation Matrices
Methodology
Performances of the aforementioned activities are being assessed through household survey and joint monitoring by local stakeholders. Likewise, the output level impacts of the executed activities are monitored jointly by central level stakeholders including policy makers, donor communities, researchers and academia. Overall impact of the activities against the stated objectives was evaluated in the fifth year of the project period with the support of international consultants. Based on these monitoring and evaluation recommendation successful initiatives have been documented, up-scaled and replicated. Household survey, remote sensing and GIS, MIS are the tools which are being used to assess performance and effectiveness of the activities.
Lesson Learned
Adoption of participatory monitoring and evaluation practice helps enhancing the capacity of local stakeholders towards institutionalizing climate change adaptation activities in local development plan and programs. Use of scientific data is important mainly to showcase the linkage of local action with global thinking like climate change and adaptation strategies and need clear legal base, policy, institution, and demarcation of understanding between development activities and adaptation programs for institutionalizing adaptation matrices
Challenges
While monitoring there should be clear demarcation between regular development activities and adaptation programs. As adaptation program cannot be limited into a single political boundary, it would be difficult to institutionalize adaptation matrices at various levels (Political units). Therefore it needs an integrated adaptation monitoring framework at central and local levels that takes into account cross sectoral and cross boundary issues. To design, implement and present the adaptation activities it is necessary to enhance the capacity of stakeholders ranging from local level to policy makers. Over and above there should be an overarching climate change adaptation plan supported by regional and local level plans and programs and they need to be linked together.

The paper was presented in a Workshop on Climate Change Adaptation Matrices in Bangladesh in March 5-6; 2011

Monday, February 14, 2011

Protected Area Management Issues in Nepal

Five days long 27th Warden Seminar was concluded on 12th February 2011. The participants were divided into three group – terai protected area, mid hills and mountain area to identify key management issues of the protected areas. Theses are the key issues of the protected areas.

1. Policy
Common
1.National Parks and Wildlife Conservation Acts, Regulations and Guidelines needs to be revised
2.Policy formulation for managing non timber forest products in protected areas is necessary
3.The revised buffer zone guidelines should include the provision of leasehold forestry program in buffer zone
4.There should be a provision of returning mountaineers fee at local level
5.There is a provision of kerosene as an alternative energy to protected area based Nepal Army personnel. Similar kind of facilities should be provided to protected area staff members
6.Protected area based Nepal Army are not effectively mobilized in buffer zone as well as national park
7.The existing ration scale of protected area staff needs to be revised
8.There should be a provision of distributing timber from buffer zone private forest to even outside of the buffer zone communities.
Terai
9.Boundary of Koshi Tappu Wildlife Reserve and Parsa Wildlife Reserve is not clear
10.There is no any program for newly declared Banke National Park Buffer Zone
11.There is no provision of using drift wood as a source of income to buffer zone communities. Because of this, annually significant amount of revenues has to be lost by the nation.

Mid Hills
1.Expedite approval process of Sagarmatha National Park Regulation, which is necessary to early implementation of the National Park and Tourism Plan that was prepared in 2005.
2.Khaptad National Park Regulation approval process need to be expedited
3.Hotel inside the protected area, mainly in Langtang National Park where over 50 hotels are in operation without paying any tax to the government should be regularized.
4.Khaptad Area Tourism Development Committee should include representatives of buffer zone and Nepal Army. Warden of Khaptad National Park should be represented in the capacity of executive director of the committee.
5.Need additional financial resources to manage Manaslu and Kanchanjunga Conservation Area. There should be a provision of returning upto 100% conservation fee to local development as in the case of Annapurna Conservation Area
6.The seminar discussed some issues that need further study like; does Makalu Barun National park need security force? Musk deer research center in Kathmandu needs to be strengthened and there are some historical sites in Shivapuri National Park which needs further exploration and renovation. There is a very few research in Khaptad National Park.

2. Institutions
1.Need a buffer zone coordination unit in Department of National Parks and Wildlife Conservation Office
2.There is an enough room for coordination amongst stakeholders. Even it is essential to maintain coordination within Nepal Army in Koshi Tappu Wildlife Reserve and Parsa Wildlife Reserve
3.Inadequate guard posts and staff number in protected areas
4.Need training to lower level protected area staff members on forest based resources identification and management
5.Protected Area based Nepal Army are facing many operational difficulties like, mobility during rainy season, motor board and river crossing equipment, vehicle arrangement for quick response, budget and infrastructure for anti poaching operation and store house of ammunition. Similarly, they are facing difficulties of infrastructures like drinking water, communication and compounding of armed post. There should be a provision of training, insurance and reward system. To work effectively, it was advised to recruit ladies in Nepal Army so as to make easy to confiscate women defaulters.
6.Almost all the buffer zone management committees were in need of an office assistant to discharge their daily activities effectively and efficiently. Even some of the low income buffer zone communities were asking for basic infrastructures support like office building and furniture.
7.Buffer zone officials were of the view that small industries in buffer zone like saw mills; brick factory etc should be registered only with the recommendation of buffer zone organizations.
8.Buffer zone needs timely availability of approved budgets
9.Buffer Zone management committee need standard format for reporting

3. Biodiversity
Biodiversity across the protected areas are threatened by poaching and illegal trade; deforestation and degradation of wildlife habitats due to encroachment for settlement expansion, over grazing, over utilization of forest based natural resources; illegal logging and trade; and ineffective management of resources and research are the key issues of biodiversity conservation in protected areas.

3.1 Species Conservation
As realized by the participants poaching and illegal trade of wildlife was common across the country. Illegal trade of non timber forest product was reported mainly from mountain protected areas.

There is an increasing number of blue sheep in Dhorpatan Hunting Reserve so it was recommended to increase license for hunting. Also, recommended to shift Blue Sheep from the status of CITES Appendix 1 to other categories so that the increasing hunting demand can be addressed. Musk deer in Godawari need special attention for management. Buffer zone communities requested to be involved in the existing anti poaching operation structure that has been formed by Nepal Army and protected area personnel.

Wetland species are declining. Koshi Tappu wildlife reserve has witnessed decreasing number of bird species. Similarly, pollution in Narayani River has posed threats to survival of fish species and Gharial Gohi.

3.2 Habitat Management
Forest encroachment has been identified as one of the major threats to biodiversity conservation across the country. Encroachment in Terai was happened mainly due to settlement expansion in the name of bonded labors and delay in evacuation of the age old settlement from all terai protected areas. Invasive species like Michaenia in Chitwan and Lantena camera in Bardia National park are succeeding wildlife habitats. In the recent days, the illegal logging has become a serious issue in Bardia National Park and Suklaphanta Wildlife Reserve.

Similarly, in Shivapuri National Park, encroachment for market expansion has been done mainly towards north of Nagarjun site. In case of Himalayan National Park, age old settlements exist inside Langtang and Sagarmatha National Parks and Manaslu and Kanchanjunga Conservation areas.

3.3 Over grazing
Some of the wild animals like black buck in Khairapur, Bardia and wild buffalo in Koshi Tappu are competing with domestic livestock for grazing. Similarly, grazing pressure is escalating in Khapad National Park.

3.4 Over utilization
Over utilization of natural resources like stone, gravel and sand have been reported from all the protected areas in Terai. Likewise, over collection of non timber forest products like Yarsha Gumba from Himalayan National Park and illegal trade of logs and NTFP resources were reported in Langtang National Park and Gaurishankar Conservation area.

3.5 Forest fire
Forest Fire is a major issue in all protected areas across the country. Forest fire has been found very destructive in planting cardamom after undertaking slash and burning.

4. Livelihood
Wildlife has been depredating livestock and damaging crop in protected area near by communities. Even, some time human casualties have been reported. Because of this, wildlife people conflict has been happened. To address this issue, the government has provisioned wildlife damage relief fund. However, this kind of fund is not provisioned for Himalayan protected areas.

Annually, large amount of land has to be lost by protected area nearby communities to the rivers in terai protected areas. They are trying to be compensated from limited Buffer Zone Fund. Therefore, participants were of the view that river cutting should be compensated by the government from other sources instead of the buffer zone development fund. Despite having enough potential, in absence of adequate infrastructures, tourism has not become a sustainable source of income to local communities in mountain protected areas.

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Concept note on Piloting Integrated Landscape Planning Framework in Mohana Kailali Corridor

Mohana Kailali Corridor

Mohana Kailali River, a boundary between Knahcnapur and Kailali has been recognized as Mohana Kailali Corridor for few years. Community forests along the eastern and western bank of the river are developed in such a way that they together have formed a corridor between Chure in the North and Dudhwa Tiger Reserve in the south. There are altogether 57 community forests including 40 in Kailali District and 17 in Kanchanpur district. In Kanchanpur the community forests are distributed in three village development committees namely Baisebichuwa, Raikawarbichuwa and Krishnapur. Similarly, towards Kailali the community forests are stretched over Dhangadi Municipality, and three VDCs such as Geta, Malakheti and Godwari.

The corridor has high conservation and livelihood value. It acts as a buffer for Laljhadi Corridor, a 16,000 hectare block of forest towards west. Until 10 years back, people of Dhanagdi had to rely on Laljhadi Forest for firewood, timber and fodder. However, after regeneration of forests along the Mohana River, the pressure on Laljhadi has been reduced noticeably.

A recent study carried out by WTLCP reveals that forest coverage has been increased significantly in this area. Likewise, the areas have evolved as a suitable habitat for dispersal animals, mainly between Dudhwa Tiger Reserve and Chure area. There are 94 bird species and more than 100 tree species. Likewise, it inhabits wildlife species like blue bull, spotted deer and wild boar. The basic need of local people mainly fodder and firewood has been fulfilled from these community forests and all forests along the eastern bank of the river have worked as live fence mainly in safeguarding people of Dhangadi Municipality from flood. With this fodder grasses facility, people re attracted towards adopting stall feeding livestock. Being market nearby, people of this area are motivated towards adopting improved livestock.

Western Terai Landscape Complex Project has supported local communities of this area with various conservation, livelihood improvement and institutional capacity building activities since 2005. With the support, a network of 24 community forests along the eastern bank called Mohana Kailali Community Forest Conservation Committee has been formed and strengthened. In addition, a coordination committee of 16 community forests along the river catchment area has been established at Godawari VDC of Kailali. Similarly, towards Kanchanpur District, coordination committees are formed and functional in three VDCs. In total, there are five coordination committees are established along the corridor - three in Kanchanpur and two in Kailali.

Need Integrated Landscape Plan
In essence, landscape level conservation advocates for integrating biodiversity conservation criteria in local development plan and programs. It requires consistent activities in corridor VDC, Municipality and DDC that ultimately lead to achieve common vision of conserving biodiversity resources at landscape level. In this backdrop, conservation activities that support landscape elements like forest ecosystem, wetland ecosystem, watershed, and grassland etc are to be included in the respective Municipality, Village Development and District Development plan and programs considering corridor area as sub set of their respective political boundary. The integrated landscape planning approach can be considered as a strategy of sustaining WTLCP supported activities in the days ahead. Considering it as a viable planning tool, WTLCP is supporting preparing an integrated management plan of Mohana Kailali Corridor in 2011.

Methodology
The integration process shall be carried out in three phases. Firstly, a management plan of the entire corridor shall be developed following stakeholder consultation and research process. Secondly, the priority activities of the management plan that are to be integrated in corridor connected local government's plan and program shall be sorted out through stakeholder consultation process. Finally, capacity of the respective local authority and community forests user committees shall be strengthened so that they together will be able to integrate biodiversity criteria in their respective periodical plan and implement coherently in the entire corridor areas.

While preparing the management plan, recently project supported study reports on biodiversity assessment and livelihood development findings will be taken as primary reference materials. In addition, various news and reports that have been produced during the project implementation period shall feed into the plan. Similarly, towards stakeholder consultation process, wider stakeholder meetings and workshops shall be carried out. The study findings and stakeholder perception shall be integrated while producing the management plan.

At the outset, efforts will be put towards developing stakeholders' ownership on the integrated plan concept as such. In this regards, through formal and informal meetings and workshops, the stakeholders shall be given with the concept note. Once they feel comfortable with the concept, the execution processes begin.

As part of integrating conservation criteria in local development plan and programs, WTLCP has already shared its annual plan in all corridor adjoining VDCs and Municipality by attending in person their ongoing planning workshops. In addition, some of the VDCs have been influenced to formulate environment related activities and allocate budgets as matching fund for WTLCP supported biodiversity conservation activities.

Deliver and Demand: Strengthening Climate Finance Governance in Nepal

https://www.spotlightnepal.com/2026/09/30/deliver-and-demand-strengthening-climate-finance-governance-nepal/ Introduction While addressing...